The Vintage Collection Webinar: Why Older Vintages Are Leading the Fine Wine Recovery

The Vintage Collection Webinar: Why Older Vintages Are Leading the Fine Wine Recovery

The Vintage Collection Webinar: Why Older Vintages Are Leading the Fine Wine Recovery

Matthew Small and Aaran Ameli-Daniel explain why older vintages are leading the fine wine recovery, and how The Vintage Collection is built.

Matthew Small and Aaran Ameli-Daniel explain why older vintages are leading the fine wine recovery, and how The Vintage Collection is built.

Written by WineFi

Written by

The Vintage Collection webinar: Ollie Thorpe, Matthew Small and Aaran Ameli-Daniel, with a chart of older versus younger vintages by region.
The Vintage Collection webinar: Ollie Thorpe, Matthew Small and Aaran Ameli-Daniel, with a chart of older versus younger vintages by region.

On Thursday 19 November 2026, WineFi hosted a live webinar on The Vintage Collection, our syndicate of mature fine wine. Matthew Small, Head of Investment, and Aaran Ameli-Daniel, Head of Data and Analytics, explained where the fine wine market stands, why older vintages are leading the recovery, and how we use data to choose wines. Ollie Thorpe, Operations Director, hosted the session and the Q&A.

The short version: older vintages held up better through the market correction, and they are rising faster in the recovery. At the same time, many new releases still cost as much as, or more than, older vintages of the same wine. The Vintage Collection is designed to buy mature wines in that gap. For the full investment case, read our introduction to The Vintage Collection.

The Vintage CollectionInvest as a group in mature fine wine, from just £3,000View the Investment Presentation

Watch the full recording below.

Key takeaways

  • The fine wine market began to recover in August 2025, after a long correction. WineFi sees the market as being in its early recovery phase.

  • Older vintages are leading that recovery. Since August 2025 they have risen 6.8%, against 2.7% for younger vintages, and they outperformed in all seven regions WineFi analysed.

  • The gap comes from a split between the primary and secondary markets. Secondary prices fell in the correction, while many release prices did not.

  • Asset selection matters as much as the asset class. Two top-scoring vintages of the same wine can be priced very differently.

  • The Vintage Collection lets you invest as a group from just £3,000, with a 4–7 years anticipated holding period. Capital is at risk.

Why invest in fine wine?

Fine wine appeals to investors for three main reasons.

Supply and demand. Fine wine improves with age. As it matures, it becomes more desirable and demand rises. Only a fixed amount is made each vintage, and supply falls over time as bottles are drunk, lost or damaged. “It’s this interplay between demand and supply that increases a wine’s value over time,” Matt said.

Diversification. Fine wine has a low correlation with equities, fixed income and commodities. It does not necessarily move in step with traditional markets, so it can add diversification to a balanced portfolio.

Tax. In many circumstances, fine wine is exempt from UK Capital Gains Tax, because HMRC treats most wine as a wasting asset: an asset with a predictable life of 50 years or less. WineFi works with tax consultants on the wines it buys, and every syndicate member receives a letter of recommendation from a third-party UK tax specialist. Tax treatment depends on your individual circumstances and may change in future. Read more in our UK wine investment tax guide.

Where is the fine wine market now?

The WineFi Trade Price Index shows where the market sits in its cycle. It follows wines that have traded at least once a quarter over the last five years. It uses trade prices, not list prices, which gives a more timely picture of where the market is heading.

The WineFi Trade Price Index, Q1 2022 to Q3 2026, with the recovery since mid-2025 highlighted.

The boom. In early 2022, the market was in a Covid-era boom. People were drinking more at home, had more disposable income as they spent less on holidays and restaurants, and central banks had expanded the money supply.

The correction. Rising interest rates ended the boom. “Fine wine is ultimately a luxury consumable,” Matt said. Higher rates reduce discretionary spending on luxury goods and make other investments more attractive. The correction that followed was long, because merchants were left holding large amounts of stock that took time to clear.

The recovery. In August 2025, the market began to stabilise. More bids came to the market and buyers returned, and that pattern has continued for over a year. “We’re in the early recovery phase,” Matt said. For more on how the market moves through booms, corrections and recoveries, see understanding fine wine market cycles.

Why are older vintages outperforming?

The gap comes from a split between two parts of the market.

  1. The secondary market has corrected. Prices for wines already trading between merchants, auction houses and exchanges fell substantially during the correction.

  2. Release prices have not. Many producers have kept new-release prices high, and some have raised them over the past four to five years.

“If you could buy an older vintage closer to its drinking window for the same price as a newly released wine, well, which would you choose?” Matt asked. Older wines also have storage and insurance costs already built into their price, and they are ready to drink sooner. Demand has shifted towards them.

The trend shows up in where wines trade. Auction houses tend to sell older, rarer vintages, while exchanges tend to trade younger, more liquid wines. Historically the two moved together, but they have diverged in recent quarters, with older, rarer wines driving the recovery.

It also shows up in broader benchmarks. WineFi’s Liv-ex 1000 +10 Vintage Composite tracks 947 wines in the Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000, each compared with the same label roughly ten vintages older. Over the five years from September 2021, the older vintages returned +1.6%. The Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000’s own wines returned −2.5%. The older wines fell less in the correction and have risen faster since.

Liv-ex 1000 +10 Vintage Composite against the Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000 wines, September 2021 to September 2026.

Older vintages have outperformed for three reasons:

  • Their prices are more established, because they have traded on the secondary market for longer.

  • They are less exposed to distortions from high release prices.

  • They are closer to their drinking window. WineFi’s analysis found that, across regions, wines have tended to underperform between release and the start of their drinking window. Demand rises as wines approach and enter their window, while supply falls as bottles are opened.

WineFi’s research supports this. Since January 2008, wines approaching or within their drinking window have returned 271.7%, against 174.3% for wines more than three years from their window. They were ahead in 77% of months. And 68.7% of newer vintages underperformed older vintages of the same label in the first 24 months after listing.

The pattern holds by region. Since the recovery began in August 2025, older vintages have outperformed younger ones in all seven major regions WineFi analysed. In the Rhône, older vintages were ahead by 5.5 percentage points, and in Burgundy by 4.7 points. In Bordeaux, older vintages rose 1.2% while younger wines fell 1.3%.

Older versus younger vintages by region: price-weighted returns from August 2025 to September 2026.

Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.

How is The Vintage Collection built?

The Vintage Collection buys only mature wines that are already within their drinking window. Its investable universe is 97 producers across six regions: Bordeaux, Burgundy, Champagne, Piedmont, the Rhône and Tuscany.

The indicative regional split is Burgundy 40%, Italy 25%, Bordeaux 15%, Champagne 15% and the Rhône 5%. This is an approximate guide, and the actual split depends on what is available to buy at the time of sourcing.

Every wine must meet four criteria:

  • A WineFi Investment Score (WIS) above 70.

  • A global liquidity score of 4 or 5 out of 5.

  • A valuation above £125 per 750ml bottle.

  • Currently within its drinking window.

Liquidity matters because a wine can age beautifully, but you still need an active secondary market to sell it. Every wine in the portfolio is chosen with a clear route to exit in mind. All purchases are also subject to satisfactory sourcing price and exit liquidity checks.

The Vintage Collection portfolio criteria and indicative regional composition.

Why asset selection matters

Not all fine wine performs alike. “Fine wine isn’t just one thing,” as Aaran put it. The wines you buy, and the price you pay, make the difference between a good return and none at all.

Domaine de la Romanée-Conti shows this. Even within a single producer, the five-year returns of its best- and worst-performing halves of wines were far apart.

Two celebrated vintages of Pétrus, 2010 and 2022, show how this plays out. Both come from highly respected years. Both have received 100-point scores from several major critics, with very similar average scores. In theory, the 2010 should cost more: it has had twelve more years in bottle and is ready to drink, so a buyer avoids years of holding costs.

In practice, the younger 2022 costs significantly more per bottle. Measured against its critic score, the 2010 trades roughly where WineFi’s analysis would expect. The 2022 trades well above that level. The 2010 has also traded more often over the past twelve months.

Pétrus 2022 versus 2010: drinking window, critic and vintage scores, trade prices, premium to score-implied price, WIS and trades in the last 12 months.

This kind of mispricing is one of the signals that can feed into WIS. The 2022 currently scores poorly on WIS. The 2010 scores in the middle of the range, below The Vintage Collection’s threshold of 70, so neither wine would qualify for the portfolio. The example shows how the model works. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any wine.

How does the WineFi Investment Score work?

WIS is a machine-learning model that ranks wines on their potential to outperform their peers over an investment period. It draws on more than 40 million historic price points and 3 million critic scores, across 110,000 investment-grade wines from over 4,000 producers. It tracks factors such as critic scores, trade prices and listings.

WIS acts as a filter before Matt’s buying process. It narrows the investment-grade universe to the wines with the strongest scores. Matt and the investment team then apply a qualitative review on top.

The model is backtested. “That means building the model in the past, not letting it see the future data,” Aaran explained, and then checking whether the wines it would have chosen outperformed the market. WineFi runs thousands of portfolio simulations to test it. Backtested results are illustrative only and are not a forecast. For a realistic view of what the asset class has delivered, read what returns can you expect from fine wine.

Your questions answered

How is the portfolio valued, and how often will members see updates?
Members can track their portfolio on the WineFi platform, where prices update daily. Valuations draw on two third-party sources, Liv-ex and Wine-Searcher, alongside TruePrice, WineFi’s own valuation model. Each quarter, WineFi reviews every portfolio in depth. Where third-party data is too thin to give a reliable valuation, WineFi uses its own data to update it.

How are sale proceeds distributed if wines are sold at different times?
WineFi monitors live bids on the wines held across its syndicates. When an attractive bid appears, members receive a recommended sell email explaining the reasons. Members own the wine, so they vote on whether to sell. If the majority vote to sell, proceeds are distributed to members pro rata, by bank transfer or Stripe payment, or held as credit for a future investment.

How do you make sure older wines have good provenance and have been stored properly?
Provenance matters even more for older wines, so WineFi uses several layers of checks:

  • WineFi buys only from trusted merchants, who carry out their own authentication and provenance checks.

  • It buys only wines that have been stored in bond, in the correct temperature, humidity and light conditions. It is very cautious about wines that predate the bond system, because there is no audit trail.

  • Before buying, the team reviews photographs of the capsule, fill levels, case and labels.

  • When the wine arrives at Coterie Vaults, partners there check that it matches the order and that the case is in the expected condition. If needed, they open the case for further checks.

Burgundy is 40% of the portfolio. How do you manage concentration risk?
Burgundy has the largest weighting because its wines currently have the highest WIS scores. But Burgundy wines also tend to be the most expensive, which is where the real concentration risk sits. WineFi sets allocations by price bracket as well as by region. A portfolio may hold one or two cases of the very top wines, priced above £1,000 a bottle, but not the majority. The aim is to balance performance with diversification.

Can I see what WineFi’s syndicates hold?
Yes. WineFi publishes the holdings and performance of each of its syndicates, alongside the relevant benchmark, on its Our Performance page.

The Vintage Collection: key terms

At the time of writing (November 2026), The Vintage Collection is open for investment.

  • Minimum investment: invest as a group from just £3,000.

  • Anticipated holding period: 4–7 years. It could be longer.

  • Backtested net annual return: 11.2%.*

  • Structure: a UK bare trust nominee, which enables the CGT exemption to pass through to syndicate members.

  • Storage: Coterie Vaults, a purpose-built, UK government approved bonded warehouse. Wines are insured at their full replacement value.

  • Governance: members hold full day-to-day control and vote on all acquisitions, disposals and management decisions.

  • Exit: wines are sold progressively over the holding period, with proceeds distributed pro rata to members.

  • Fees: a single upfront fee covering sourcing, structuring, fully insured storage and management: 12.5% for £3,000–£9,999, 11.25% for £10,000–£24,999, and 10% for £25,000 and above.

*Derived from backtesting on historic data (2002–2026) across five-year investment periods from 2009 onwards, applying The Vintage Collection syndicate criteria. Net of fees. Backtested figures are illustrative only. They are not a forecast and are not a reliable indicator of future returns.

What are the risks?

Fine wine is an alternative and illiquid asset class. It should only form a small part of a well-diversified portfolio.

  • Capital at risk: the value of your investment can go down as well as up, and you may not get back the full amount you invested.

  • Illiquidity: the anticipated holding period is 4–7 years, but it could be longer. Exit opportunities are uncertain.

  • Market conditions: trends in the wine market do not guarantee future outcomes. The conditions described here may not last.

  • Unregulated: WineFi is not regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, and direct investment in fine wine is not an FCA-regulated activity. FSCS and Financial Ombudsman protection is unlikely to apply.

  • Physical storage: despite professional storage and insurance, there is a risk of damage, fire, contamination or theft.

  • Tax: tax treatment depends on your circumstances and may change.

Further reading

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Who spoke at The Vintage Collection webinar?

Matthew Small, Head of Investment at WineFi, and Aaran Ameli-Daniel, Head of Data and Analytics. Ollie Thorpe, Operations Director, hosted.

Why are older fine wine vintages outperforming younger ones?

Secondary market prices fell during the correction, while many new-release prices stayed high. Older vintages now often cost the same as, or less than, younger vintages of the same wine, despite being closer to their drinking window. Since August 2025, older vintages have risen 6.8%, against 2.7% for younger vintages. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns.

What is the minimum investment in The Vintage Collection?

Members invest as a group from just £3,000. Fees are charged once, upfront, at 12.5%, 11.25% or 10% depending on the amount invested.

How long is the investment held?

The anticipated holding period is 4–7 years. Wines are sold progressively over that period, and the period could be longer.

How are older wines checked for provenance?

WineFi buys only from trusted merchants and only wines stored in bond. The team reviews photographs before buying, and the wine is checked again on arrival at Coterie Vaults.

The Vintage CollectionInvest as a group in mature fine wine, from just £3,000View the Investment Presentation

Capital at risk. Fine wine is an unregulated asset class and the value of your portfolio may fall as well as rise. Fine wine is an alternative and illiquid asset class and should only form a small part of a well-diversified portfolio. You may not get back the full amount you invested. Past performance and backtested returns are not reliable indicators of future returns. This article is for information only and is not tax, legal or investment advice. If in doubt, take independent professional advice.

Sources: The Vintage Collection webinar, 19 November 2026. WineFi analysis as at 30/09/2026, using latent trade prices (WineFi TruePrice) built from merchant, auction and exchange secondary trade data. Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000 from Liv-ex. Older vintages: 1998–2014 (Champagne 1994–2004). Younger: 2015–2023 (Champagne 2005–2023). Pétrus comparison: WineFi TruePrice, 18 November 2026.

Capital is at risk. Wine values can go down as well as up, and investments may not perform as expected. Returns may vary. You should not invest more than you can afford to lose. WineFi is not authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority. Investments are not regulated and you will have no access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) or the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS). Past performance and forecasts are not reliable indicators of future results and should not be relied on. Forecasts are based on WineFi’s own internal calculations and opinions and may change. Investments are illiquid. Once invested, you are committed for the full term. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances and may change.


You are advised to obtain appropriate tax or investment advice where necessary.


WineFi is a trading name of WineFi Management Limited. Registered in England and Wales with registration number: 14864655 and whose registered office is at 5th Floor, 167-169 Great Portland Street, London, United Kingdom, W1W 5PF.